I'm no fan of this set, or Gypsy Queen, which is the same difference as far as I'm concerned, but since so many of you are busting hobby boxes of A&G right now, I wanted to alert you to a thread I caught on Blowout that's relevant to your interests.
Apparently, rippers extraordinaire brentandbecca noticed something while bulldozing through a ridiculous 384 boxes: three of the box LIDS contained rare 1/1 cards. The good: this is a very cool, unexpected bonus for you die-hards that bust boxes of the stuff every year. The bad: nobody seemed to have been aware of this, and a number of these cards may come out damaged, if not entirely thrown out with the bathwater, as it were, by collectors who tear into their newest obsession.
I lean on the positive side, although I think Topps could have done a bit more to prevent damage by unsuspecting box-rippers. Those of you who've opened one or more hobby boxes should definitely check them for these cards if you haven't already.
That magazine with the made-up prices and delusional editor has more details on the story here. Much better hobby news source the Cardboard Connection also has more on the news. Good luck to you collectors, and well wishes to all the Gint-a-Cuffs participants this year!
Showing posts with label Beckett. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beckett. Show all posts
Saturday, August 10, 2013
Monday, July 9, 2012
Beckett, as in wreck-it
I had hoped to regale you all with some trade post goodness today, but instead I feel obligated to tackle a different topic: Beckett. I have two primary motivations for doing so, one being that I had already intended to add my two cents to what a couple other bloggers already discussed in their excellent posts, and the other being how one of the biggest detriments to the hobby has treated one of our own.
In case you didn't see all of this, Play at the Plate featured a great response to a $30 a Week Habit post that was written in response to another PATP article.
To sum up, PATP looked at what collecting was like when MLB wasn't killing the hobby with the Toppsopoly and we were on the opposite extreme--too many choices--and wonders if we're better off. $30aWH then puts his own spin on things with an alternate universe in which "the magazine" doesn't exist. PATP plays off this and decides that Beckett is obsolete, not to mention inaccurate. (While I'm discussing what these two excellent bloggers did, I'd like to point out just how much I appreciate what they and all you other guys do: provide a great community that can foster discussion like this in a coherent manner that literally doesn't exist anywhere else, ESPECIALLY on beckett.com.)
Though I haven't exactly timely with my posts, I thought I'd briefly discuss my experiences as a collector who grew up during Beckett's heyday.
When I was very young my parents apparently bought some cards for me and my brother, which I know because we played with them until we got a bit older and understood the concept of collecting. I'm pretty sure they were factory sets of '89 Donruss and Topps because I had a bunch of those, though not necessarily the better cards in either set. We then picked up the occasional packs, and eventually--though I can't remember how--came into knowledge of the yearly Beckett price guide books, which were available at our library. That segued into our discovery of Beckett, which introduced to us the idea of "value" as it pertained to sports cards. I definitely enjoyed collecting the magazine and still have all my issues from when I subscribed, plus a bunch of older ones I picked up through various means. And for quite a while, I did what many others did and swore by the "book" prices when it came to buying, selling and trading online and at shows.
That made for good and bad moments. There were plenty of times we'd pull something rare from a wax box or dig something out of a closet, look it up and discover it was "worth" way more than we thought. Then again, reality would come crashing down on us when we found out a $20 card didn't ever sell for $20. But more importantly it could impact trading (again, most of which we did online, especially initially through Beckett's Buy/Sell area) when you or your partner didn't feel you were getting "equal value" according to the price guide. It didn't matter if you were giving up better overall cards or if you were just a few bucks apart--usually at that point the deal died.
In the last couple years I definitely got away from trading (and selling, really) while continuing to acquire stuff, mainly through boxes, many of which proved disappointing, as they can at times. The few times I did, though, along with the occasions where I'd open a box or acquire something, I would still swear by the card Bible. What saved me from that limited collecting life was following collecting blogs. As I started to notice people throwing around trade packages without a care for value, I gained a new-found energy for collecting myself because I thought "THIS is exactly what trading should be." Really, it's about as pure as it gets aside from most of it taking place online these days, but then again, it opens up so many more trade possibilities, especially when you can easily work with a Dodgers fan all the way across the country.
What I'm getting at is that during my collecting years when I held fast to the magazine, I enjoyed a relatively OK collecting experience, but since then, I've finally grown up and realized just how obsolete it really is, both in terms of the price guide and its various features. These days you'll hear sellers on forums swear by eBay prices (which is at least slightly more accurate, if not completely) which are a million times more "real-time" than Beckett's false claims. That, and, as Brian pointed out, you're no longer stuck with Beckett as the only game in town for box breaks; instead of reading about their suspiciously good fortune with one outstanding box, you can get a ridiculous sample size including scans and video. And don't get me started about pimping the next big thing. It's a shame that magazines like Beckett can't sometimes discuss the more negative aspects of the hobby--constructively, with a dialogue about how things can improve--and instead choose to be blissfully unaware of monopolies, fakes, and other real problems.
All of that led me to ditch Beckett as a price guide once and for all a couple years ago. I continue to use the site as a checklist resource but otherwise studiously ignore it, since that's the best thing to do in this case. That's worked out just fine for me, especially since I'd quickly grown sick of the shenanigans of major players like Chris Olds, et al. However, recently, something happened to one of my favorite bloggers that I couldn't let stand.
Here are some facts about Greg Z. of Plaschke Thy Sweater is Argyle:
Because of all of that, Beckett is officially dead to me. If anyone ever comes to me in a deal and quotes the "Beckett" price I'll just give them this look,
Good luck all the same to a great blogger everyone knows and loves. VOTE FOR GREG Z!
Update: this one's for Eric L!:
In case you didn't see all of this, Play at the Plate featured a great response to a $30 a Week Habit post that was written in response to another PATP article.
| Still with me? |
| Pissed Off Card Collector FTW |
When I was very young my parents apparently bought some cards for me and my brother, which I know because we played with them until we got a bit older and understood the concept of collecting. I'm pretty sure they were factory sets of '89 Donruss and Topps because I had a bunch of those, though not necessarily the better cards in either set. We then picked up the occasional packs, and eventually--though I can't remember how--came into knowledge of the yearly Beckett price guide books, which were available at our library. That segued into our discovery of Beckett, which introduced to us the idea of "value" as it pertained to sports cards. I definitely enjoyed collecting the magazine and still have all my issues from when I subscribed, plus a bunch of older ones I picked up through various means. And for quite a while, I did what many others did and swore by the "book" prices when it came to buying, selling and trading online and at shows.
That made for good and bad moments. There were plenty of times we'd pull something rare from a wax box or dig something out of a closet, look it up and discover it was "worth" way more than we thought. Then again, reality would come crashing down on us when we found out a $20 card didn't ever sell for $20. But more importantly it could impact trading (again, most of which we did online, especially initially through Beckett's Buy/Sell area) when you or your partner didn't feel you were getting "equal value" according to the price guide. It didn't matter if you were giving up better overall cards or if you were just a few bucks apart--usually at that point the deal died.
In the last couple years I definitely got away from trading (and selling, really) while continuing to acquire stuff, mainly through boxes, many of which proved disappointing, as they can at times. The few times I did, though, along with the occasions where I'd open a box or acquire something, I would still swear by the card Bible. What saved me from that limited collecting life was following collecting blogs. As I started to notice people throwing around trade packages without a care for value, I gained a new-found energy for collecting myself because I thought "THIS is exactly what trading should be." Really, it's about as pure as it gets aside from most of it taking place online these days, but then again, it opens up so many more trade possibilities, especially when you can easily work with a Dodgers fan all the way across the country.
What I'm getting at is that during my collecting years when I held fast to the magazine, I enjoyed a relatively OK collecting experience, but since then, I've finally grown up and realized just how obsolete it really is, both in terms of the price guide and its various features. These days you'll hear sellers on forums swear by eBay prices (which is at least slightly more accurate, if not completely) which are a million times more "real-time" than Beckett's false claims. That, and, as Brian pointed out, you're no longer stuck with Beckett as the only game in town for box breaks; instead of reading about their suspiciously good fortune with one outstanding box, you can get a ridiculous sample size including scans and video. And don't get me started about pimping the next big thing. It's a shame that magazines like Beckett can't sometimes discuss the more negative aspects of the hobby--constructively, with a dialogue about how things can improve--and instead choose to be blissfully unaware of monopolies, fakes, and other real problems.
All of that led me to ditch Beckett as a price guide once and for all a couple years ago. I continue to use the site as a checklist resource but otherwise studiously ignore it, since that's the best thing to do in this case. That's worked out just fine for me, especially since I'd quickly grown sick of the shenanigans of major players like Chris Olds, et al. However, recently, something happened to one of my favorite bloggers that I couldn't let stand.
Here are some facts about Greg Z. of Plaschke Thy Sweater is Argyle:
- Greg is an excellent, very well-respected blogger
- Greg loves his Dodgers and collects the hell out of them (key word here: "collects")
- Greg made it into a Beckett-run contest as one of three finalists, one of which would win a Sandy Koufax autograph
- Many people, especially his fellow bloggers and collectors would like to see him win this contest because he'd, you know, KEEP the thing and enjoy it as a Dodgers collector
But THEN,
one of the three finalists, a total asshat who sang a Justin Beiber song and should have been automatically disqualified except he was such an asshat even Chris Olds was like, "Whoa, this guy is REALLY an asshat. I'm not mad, that's amazing!" decided to literally buy votes. In a respectful manner, Greg pointed this out. Olds' response, which took a while because he had to manually remove him from Topps' nuts and sit him in front of the only keyboard in the world that's large enough for his fat fingers, was this:
That's right: when Greg came forward with evidence that one of his competitors was cheating and--once again--literally BUYING VOTES, then others piled on by reasonably pointing out how ridiculously unfair that was, Chris referred to these people as "complainers" making "mud-slinging allegations" and made them all sound ungrateful. Luckily for everyone, next time he'll save us "the hassles" (didn't know it was possible to have more than one) and pick someone himself, which is simply what he should have done in the first place, except Mr. Olds is apparently unaware that they have the Internet on computers now, and said computers can be used to break any poll or contest. When I tried to point that out, my comment was, to my utter shock, not approved by their moderator.
Because of all of that, Beckett is officially dead to me. If anyone ever comes to me in a deal and quotes the "Beckett" price I'll just give them this look,
and go on my merry way. As for the people behind "the magazine" that embody everything that's wrong with the hobby,
| You stay classy, Beckett, and go fuck yourselves. |
Good luck all the same to a great blogger everyone knows and loves. VOTE FOR GREG Z!
Update: this one's for Eric L!:
Tuesday, January 24, 2012
Blogger league...ASSEMBLE!
So once again I'm crowdsourcing some information I don't have handy--I'm working on selling some of my trade bait that's just kinda been sitting there so I get some use out of it and don't feel so guilty about spending as much as I do on cards. While I don't bow down to the holy Bible of sports card pricing, Beckett, I'm out of options here because I can't get market value prices from COMC or completed eBay listings.
SO, the question is, do any of you have a subscription to either Beckett Baseball or Football, or the OPGs? I'm really just looking for prices on two cards:
Mikie Mahtook/Brian Johnson 2010 Bowman Sterling Refractor dual auto
C.J. Spiller 2010 Press Pass Wal-Mart Exclusives auto #d /25 (bottom middle)
I know the Spiller might be too rare to be priced, which is fine. But if any of you can help me with prices on either or both of the cards, I would very much appreciate it and could make it up to you in cards or assistance to be named later (answering computer questions would probably be my most valuable non-card service I could offer). So if you can help, please let me know. Thanks in advance!
SO, the question is, do any of you have a subscription to either Beckett Baseball or Football, or the OPGs? I'm really just looking for prices on two cards:
Mikie Mahtook/Brian Johnson 2010 Bowman Sterling Refractor dual auto
C.J. Spiller 2010 Press Pass Wal-Mart Exclusives auto #d /25 (bottom middle)
I know the Spiller might be too rare to be priced, which is fine. But if any of you can help me with prices on either or both of the cards, I would very much appreciate it and could make it up to you in cards or assistance to be named later (answering computer questions would probably be my most valuable non-card service I could offer). So if you can help, please let me know. Thanks in advance!
Monday, August 22, 2011
It's like a virtual card show for about two-fiddy, plus WTF Chris Olds?
Mandatory Blowout purchase section:
Yadda, yadda, Blowout, right? I realize I just did the mad libs thing, so I'll just keep this one simple: six cards for $17 as they were $2.50 each out of the guy's Picasa Web Album (which he was still calling a Bucket for some reason). I grabbed three for me and three that were trade bait, which explains the card show reference in the title--almost every time I go I get about 50% PC stuff and 50% trade bait, but never on purpose.
Trade bait:
- Brooks Foster 2009 Bowman Draft College Letter Patch Auto "R" (#039/173) (North Carolina)
- Aaron Brooks 2001 Topps Reserve auto
- Syndric Steptoe 2007 Leaf R&S patch/auto/RC (#093/299)
The Steptoe is destined to go to Tim, and if he doesn't take it, he'll be dead to me (people will say "Did you see Tim's latest post?" and I'll say "Yeah, it's a shame the way he went, though, at the fireworks factory--who would have thought he'd get run over by a clown car there?").
The other two are up for grabs for now. The Brooks is a BA Benny-preferred card, but I'm certainly open to offers since I probably have more than enough to send his way.
Now for the stuff for me:
Adrian Arrington 2008 SP Rookie Threads Signing Day auto: I'll start by saying I really like the design on these for some reason. It might be the way the autograph section really pops, plus you can't really tell it's a sticker until you look up-close because it's clear. It doesn't hurt that Arrington has an interesting autograph. This is #18 of him in my collection and continues my streak of nothing but autographs of the former Michigan WR.Charles Woodson 2006 Fleer Fabrics jersey: W00t for doubling my Woodson hit collection. Although he's pictured here as a Raider and the swatch might actually be from a black Oakland jersey (I really can't tell), I'm counting this as a Packers card because that's the listed team, that's who he just won the Super Bowl with, plus Oakland just outderped themselves and spent a THIRD-ROUND PICK in the supplemental draft on Terrell "Everybody murders" Pryor.
Jason Avant 2006 Prestige jersey RC: A nice green rookie-year swatch of the sure-handed receiver. I'm hoping for good things for Avant with Vick QBing now that he has a full year under his belt back from suspension. This is Avant #17 for me, by the way.
Look for more, as usual, pretty soon, including another very exciting addition to one of my baseball PCs!
WTF, Chris Olds?:
I generally object to many of the things that Beckett's editor Chris Olds does--his box breaks annoy me to no end, and of course he's part of the "Hobby has never been better" up-your-ass smoke-blowing committee--but I picked today to ask "WTF?" about his latest piece of "journalism." Here, Olds explains why Bull Durham is not his #1 baseball movie. So far, so good--I'm not sure it's mine, either, and I have a hard time choosing one above the rest. His main beef is that the teams Durham plays in the movie are geographically ridiculous and overall inaccurate.
While I disagree with this as a major reason to knock a movie down on your list, I don't dispute his right to use whatever criteria to order it. What I'm most annoyed by is that the article/editorial has zero purpose: it's very short, its lazily-written, and most importantly, it doesn't even mention what his #1 baseball movie IS. If you enjoy one-to-two sentence paragraphs explaining inaccuracies and literally nothing else, you're in for a treat.
While I disagree with this as a major reason to knock a movie down on your list, I don't dispute his right to use whatever criteria to order it. What I'm most annoyed by is that the article/editorial has zero purpose: it's very short, its lazily-written, and most importantly, it doesn't even mention what his #1 baseball movie IS. If you enjoy one-to-two sentence paragraphs explaining inaccuracies and literally nothing else, you're in for a treat.
It's crap like this that really makes me appreciate my fellow bloggers for the interesting and often insightful content they bring every day. I won't pretend that as an English major I don't cringe at the usual array of spelling and grammatical errors that come with the territory (I'm only human!) but at worst I still get about 10 blogs worth of content a day from my subscriptions that trump the drivel Beckett's editor decided to crap out today. Maybe Beckett needs to do a better job of incorporating user-generated content from, you know, the collectors that give its magazine a reason for existence (or, not really since its been a long time since the prices have been anything but obsolete). That's my long way of saying, "WTF, Chris Olds?" and it may not be the last time I do.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










