2025 trade package #10: Sport Card Collectors

We're in mid-June and the MLB season is getting close to the halfway point, but things were just getting started for my Tigers and the other clubs back in April when Matt of the Sport Card Collectors family of blogs sent me a cool pair of PWEs mostly featuring that team.

Here's what Matt sent me this time:

Bowman is often the home of prospects you've never heard of (and likely won't ever hear from again), and Ardoin's no exception--he pitched just three years of Minor League ball. Miggy and I were both six years old when the '89 Topps set the insert above is based on came out, and one of us went on to a storied MLB career. '24 World Series winner Flaherty is back in Detroit's rotation, and the results have been somewhat mixed, but he's still a solid guy I'm glad is on the team (plus, who'd say no to a Refractor?).

When it comes to infielder Colt Keith, he wouldn't be born for another 12 years after '89 Topps' release, and he made his MLB debut a total of 35 years after the abundant firestarter was found in packs, as seen on a cool Topps parallel. While '25 has been a bit of a down year for Keith, Torkelson has reversed his fortunes and is playing like a Star of the MLB, on pace to exceed the 31 bombs he totaled two years ago.

'84 World Series champ Trammell looks regal on a recent Panini Crusade design, and though he was famously screwed out of the '87 AL MVP, he does have a better crown to wear: MVP of the previously mentioned World Series. Verlander, meanwhile, has a trophy case absolutely stuffed thanks to a ROY, MVP, three Cy Youngs, and two World Series rings, not to mention an ALCS MVP. Autumn wasn't kind to him until 2017 with the Astros, and the third time was the charm for Mr. Kate Upton. As always he also looks great in Refractor form.

There were two more baseball items in these envelopes, both of diminutive stature. The first is a Mini Miggy, not to be confused with erstwhile Tiger Avisail Garcia, and the second is a Ginter Mini of 2008-09 and 2012 Tigers OF Clete Thomas, who ended his brief MLB career with the Twins in 2013.

Matt's also one of my more consistent sources of Michigan Football stuff, which I always appreciate, and he included a couple recent defensive guys here. First is a '24 Score RC of LB Junior Colson, who was drafted by his former college coach Jim Harbaugh and the Chargers, for whom he played 11 games last season. As always, hell yeah to the occasional college action RC! The other is a Panini Mosaic base of Aidan Hutchinson, the beastly edge player whose return to health could portend even more success than last year's Lions. My collection of the Lions' best player is growing nicely and is nearing the 50-card mark thanks to envelopes like this one.

Matt, as always, thank you for more of your trademark PWEs as they always include some of my PC favorites. Pretty soon I should also be able to cover the newest pair you sent this month, though I have a bit more catching up to do. In the meantime I look forward to any post(s) you put together on the envelope I just sent your way.

As this was my lone trade package from April I don't have too much more to show off from that month, but I'll be back soon with an outstanding showing of generosity. 

2024 Facebook purchase: the Champs Feel a Draft

In case I haven't mentioned it lately, the Michigan Wolverines football team won the 2023 NCAA Championship. Yep, they did that! 15-0 including beating Ohio State for the third year in a row, taking the Big Ten Conference crown (ditto), triumphing over Alabama in an instant Rose Bowl classic, and finally suffocating Washington to put the icing on the cake.

I knew I planned to celebrate by buying various memorabilia to help me enjoy what's sure to be a once-in-a-lifetime type of team, and one of those purchases came about a week after the last of the confetti fell in Houston.

A Facebook Marketplace seller had listed complete 110-card sets of the NIL-funding 2023 Valiant Michigan Wolverines base cards, and while I skipped last year's due to the cost, I knew I wanted one from this past season. He was asking $175 each, and I talked him down to $150 each for two of them by meeting up with him and paying cash--one for me, and one for Jeff, naturally.

It worked out nicely for both the seller and me, despite being an absolutely skin-burningly freezing day where I was bouncing all over frozen drifts of snow. The guy had clearly bought a lot of packs and was making money back selling sets while compiling the autographs and other cool stuff.

I got back home, built the checklist, uploaded it to TCDb, and then got to work scanning the fronts and backs of all 110 cards. And now that I'm catching up from January, I thought today, the last day of the 2024 draft, would be a great day to recap them a bit.

Don't worry, I won't show off all 110 cards; You can head here to see the whole thing if you feel like it. But I am going to do a quick run through of the guys in the set who got drafted this year, the players still available as UDFAs, and a few stars that are sticking around for at least one more season.

First, here's a look at a typical front and back courtesy of scary returning DL Kenneth Grant. You've got white borders on two edges, black accents, number/player/position info inside maize and blue sections, and part of that iconic winged helmet up front. The photos of college action look great, and in a corner you can see the logo of Valiant, the marketing company that funnels money from purchases of these and other items to the players.

The back offers a different helmet, more of the same name/number/position data, a bit of biographic info, and notes from their Michigan and high school careers. These cards are unnumbered and I sorted them alphabetically by last name.

On to the draftees:

J.J. McCarthy (QB): 10th overall (first round), Minnesota Vikings

A few players got two cards and it's no surprise that the former five-star that promised to get the team back to the playoff and win it all is one of them. He'll take his athleticism and zen mindset to Minnesota to eventually replace absolute chud Kirk Cousins.

Kris Jenkins (DT): 49th overall (second round), Cincinnati Bengals

Jenkins was part of a defense that consistently stifled opponents, and he finished with career highs in TFL (4.5) and sacks (2.5) while also tacking on a fat guy interception.

Mike Sainristil (CB): 50th overall (second round), Washington Commanders

The converted WR who made the play of The Game against OSU in '21, Mikey is the embodiment of this team and played with zero selfishness after a positional switch. He made big plays and got to wear the Turnover Buffs very often. He'll be a football coach and/or US president when all is said and done.

Junior Colson (LB): 69th overall (round 3), Los Angeles Chargers

Colson is another bigger name guy that gets two cards here. He didn't put up gaudy numbers but was ultimately reliable in his three college seasons. His reaction to former college coach and new NFL boss Jim Harbaugh "choosing him again" was heartwarming.

Blake Corum (RB): 83rd overall (round 3), Los Angeles Rams

What else can you say about "Blake the Great?" The RB with tree trunks for legs isn't a speed burner but he was almost automatic at moving the chains and getting into the end zone from 10 yards out or less. The program TD leader leaves a legacy of big plays in big moments.

Roman Wilson (WR): 84th overall (round 3), Pittsburgh Steelers

The Hawaiian WR more than earned his #1 jersey by becoming a favorite target of McCarthy, finishing with 48 receptions, 12 of which were scores. His TD catch against a Nebraska player's helmet will be a highlight for years, but no play was bigger than the rising catch he made in comeback mode against Alabama in the Rose Bowl.

Zak Zinter (OG): 85th overall (round 3), Cleveland Browns

Zinter was a huge piece of the interior of an O-line that protected McCarthy and run-blocked for Corum and the other running backs, so when he went down with a broken leg in the OSU game, the team could have folded. Instead, Blake Corum scored a TD for "6-5" on the very next play, and the team finished their job without missing a beat.

A.J. Barner (TE): 121st overall (round 4), Seattle Seahawks

The Indiana transfer made the best decision of his life heading northeast to Ann Arbor for the '23 season. Though his numbers don't stand out, he appeared in all 15 games and got himself drafted after proving himself to be a solid TE2.

Trevor Keegan (OG): 172nd overall (round 5), Philadelphia Eagles

Another absolute monster that fits the stereotype of offensive linemen, he'll likely be a fan favorite on a team that just saw Jason Kelce retire.

Michael Barrett (LB): 240th overall (round 7), Carolina Panthers

Michael Barrett is a guy who'd been around since the 2019 season, meaning he saw the lows of the goofy 2020 COVID campaign and still stuck around through everything. His reward: glory and lots of hardware.

(No card) LaDarius Henderson (OT): 249th overall (round 7), Houston Texans

The Arizona State transfer tackle doesn't appear in this set, but he did a sold job at that position despite not being a star. Very cool that he gets to hang out with fellow Wolverine Nico Collins and troll his QB about winning The Game.

Jaylen Harrell (EDGE): 252nd overall (round 7), Tennessee Titans

I believe Harrell had another year of eligibility left but obviously opted to forgo that, and there's nothing wrong with going out on top. He improved on a pretty nice '22 season--7.5 TFL and 3.5 sacks, with 9.0 and 6.5, respectively, along with a pair of forced fumbles.

Cornelius Johnson (WR): 253rd overall (seventh round), Los Angeles Chargers

While Michigan didn't break the record of 15 players drafted, CJ's former/new coach Harbaugh made him #13, a program record. He scored just one TD on 47 receptions in a run-heavy offense that tended to favor Roman Wilson and the TEs, but he was often reliable with an occasional drop. The replays of him torching OSU DBs for long catch-and-run TDs will forever be burned in my brain.

A few ex-Wolverines who were also drafted:

• Xavier Worthy (WR), #28, Chiefs: he doesn't really count but was a one-time commit who couldn't enroll due to some of the usual admissions ridiculousness that tends to happen around here. I'm happy that he went on to have a great career at Texas that earned him a first-round selection
• Erick All (TE), #115 (4th round), Bengals: a very talented TE, All will forever be remembered for a game winning catch-and-run score against Penn State in '21. Injuries shortened his '22 season and then he transferred to Iowa, only to have his season cut short there. It's nice to see him get a chance in the league.
• Joe Milton (QB), #193 (6th round), Patriots: a QB that could amaze you and baffle you on consecutive plays, Milton opened the 2020 season with a bang, then lost his job to Cade McNamara. He could throw the ball the length of the field and sometimes even within a few yards of one of his teammates. He put up 20 TDs through the air and another seven on the ground in his third and final season with Tennessee, and reportedly isn't interested in a position switch. We'll see how that works out.

The following players, most of whom were in the set, are now undrafted free agents:

Karsen Barnhart (OG)

I'm a bit surprised the Paw Paw native didn't get drafted, but at least the team valued his versatility in Ann Arbor, where he played all along the OL except for center.

Trente Jones (OL)

Jones is one of a number of guys who could have come back, and in his case he very likely would have been able to put more on film after being a swing lineman, filling in ably as needed and working well in jumbo sets.

Braiden McGregor (EDGE)

I believe McGregor is another guy that could have stuck around for one more season. He put up career highs with 9.0 TFL and 4.5 sacks along with a forced fumble, and he made some important plays, though didn't pop up as much as some of the team's bigger stars.

(No card) Drake Nugent (C)

A transfer from conference foe Nebraska, Nugent came in and handled the center position well. I guess some of the transfers just didn't make it in time to be part of the set for whatever reason.

(No card) Josh Wallace (CB)

Wallace transferred in from UMass as a grad student and quietly had a pretty solid season that ended with some excellent plays in the two playoff games.

Two other former players who transferred also went undrafted (and weren't part of this set):

1. Eyabi Okie-Anoma (EDGE): a bit of a nomad, he suited up for Alabama in 2018, Michigan in 2022, and Charlotte last year.
2. Taylor Upshaw (DE): Upshaw was a Wolverine from 2019-2022 then headed to Arizona for his final season. He finished with 8.5 sacks but missed out on winning a title.

Finally, here's a few returning stars from the set who we'll get to see in 2024:

Donovan Edwards (RB)

Mason Graham (DL)

Will Johnson (CB)

Colston Loveland (TE)

Semaj Morgan (WR)

Alex Orji (QB)

That takes care of the 2024 draft for now, at least until I can start buying up and trading for cards of some of the above players. I'll be back with more posts soon but until then, as always, GO BLUE!

2023 trade package #27: Sport Card Collectors

It's the holiday season for sure--less than a week until Christmas--and I continue to receive cards from generous folks at a ridiculous pace. I may not (hell, I definitely won't) be caught up before the end of the year but that's a nice problem to have.

For now I'll make a small effort in support of that goal by covering the first of a few trade packages I received in November. That would be a pair of PWEs from Matt of several blogs that I may just continue to refer to collectively as "Sport Card Collectors" for my own convenience. Funny story: he sent the envelopes the same day but only one arrived to me a few days later. We both wondered if the other one got lost and then it just randomly showed up a few weeks later, even slipping past Informed Delivery as some mail is wont to do. Either way, they both got here safely, and inside them were these:

I'd certainly like Baez to be a star of the MLB considering what he's making and the amount of payroll he's eating up, but if he can even return to his level of performance from 2022 that would help. Cabrera played for so long that sometimes it feels like he debuted in 1987, when we both turned four. Up there you see one of a pair of dupes Matt sent which I was happy to have since I know plenty of people that could use something like that. The Sepia Refractor looks excellent and as always I love images of his outstanding swing, putting him in a club with guys like Junior Griffey.

Next, the foil parallel of Miggy and Riley Greene--a '23 Topps team checklist--is very cool since it shows what's now the past and future of the franchise, as tough as it is to refer to Cabrera in the past tense. If Greene can stay healthy he could be a franchise favorite for years to come! 

The rest of this scan is made up of pitchers still with the team. With a couple new rotation additions in Kenta Maeda and Jack Flaherty, there's much less pressure on guys like the super talented Manning, who could benefit from some veteran guidance. His Panini Mosaic and a Pink Chrome Refractor here put me just shy of 30 cards of the 25-year-old. Fellow first-rounder Mize is also a Pink Refractor, should also be part of the starting five next year, though a return from TJ surgery makes him a bit less of a sure thing. What's unquestionable is that my collection of his has grown even faster than Manning's as that's card #68 for me! Meanwhile, I'm happy to see Wentz in Purple Refractor form, though until he starts performing in a way that isn't detrimental to his team (3-13, 6.90 ERA in '23), the less we see of him the better. It's much less likely the team will need him next season, though, which is good news.

The last of the baseball stuff is, naturally, a new Verlander for me. JV's appeared in Heritage's Then and Now insert a bunch since 2010 and has been paired up with the following:

• Whitey Ford (2010)
• Sandy Koufax (2012)
• Juan Marichal (2012)
• Jim Bunning (2013)
• Bob Gibson (2013)
• Fergie Jenkins (2017)
• Jim Palmer (2019)
• Catfish Hunter (2020)
• Jim Palmer (2020)
• Gaylord Perry (2023)
• Catfish Hunter (2023)

This is the first time he joins "Garylord" (WTF are you even doing, Topps?) Perry in the set, though Marichal is his top comp of the group in Baseball Reference's Similarity Scores. Regardless, that's heady company when you're compared to a group like that!

Matt also included a bit of football content, and I'm glad it can be easier for some of you when guys I collect appear in their college unis in products like Bowman Chrome University. Colson's a LB who'll be appearing in at least 14 games for the third straight season, with game #14 once again being a playoff tilt. His stats are down a bit from some excellent numbers last season but he's still been very solid at the position for an outstanding defense that consistently puts the team in position to win. Once again I didn't mind the dupes here because I can think of at least one person who could use it.

Thanks again for these envelopes, Matt, and I hope you didn't stress too much when one of them disappeared off the face of the earth. I'm looking forward to showing off what you sent me for Christmas once I get a bit more caught up, and in the meantime may you enjoy the package you have sitting under your tree!

More trade recaps to come soon!